|
Chapter Four: Developing the Group Climate
Competitive versus Cooperative Climates
 A positive climate exists when individuals perceive they are valued and treated well by the group.
 Prevention is preferred to cure
 Establishing a positive group climate of trust, openness, directness, and accomplishment will prevent many problems from occurring, thus making cures for hostile conflict and disruptive dissension among members largely irrelevant.
 A positive climate is far more likely to develop into a cooperative instead of a competitive atmosphere.
Attitudes are nothing more than habits and thoughts
and habits can be acquired,
An action repeated, becomes an attitude realized.
Paul Meier
Competition is a process of mutually exclusive goal attainment (MEGA)
Competition necessitates the failure of many for the success of few.
Cooperation is a process of mutually inclusive goal attainment. (MIGA)
Your success is tied directly to the success of other group members.
"We must all hang together--
or, most assuredly, we shall all hang separately."
Benjamin Franklin
Individual Achievement is being better than before and is attained at no one else's expense (It is not competition in no one looses)
Prevalence of competition
Our inclination to view most human interactions in a competitive light is real and pervasive.
"Conversation in the United States is a competitive exercise
in which the first person to draw a breath is declared the listener."
Nathan Miller
If cooperation in We-oriented and competition is me-oriented, how can competitive pattern of interaction be anything but incompetent communication.
Effects of competition versus cooperation
Achievement and performance
 In studies, there were clear advantages of cooperation over competition on achievement and performance.
 Even the worst cooperative groups that were relatively weak on task accomplishment, on average, outperformed the best competitive groups.
 Resources are used more effectively in a cooperative atmosphere.
 Competition diminishes performance because of the antagonism associated with beating others.
 Anywhere from 50% to 80% of adolescents who participate in sports quit because they aren't having any fun and the pressure to win is too great.
 Highly competitive coaches had a team dropout rate five times greater than teams coached by a more cooperative amateur who emphasized skill development, not winning.
Group cohesiveness
Groups can become more cohesive if they have competition with another group; however, this is a questionable way to achieve such a result.
Self-esteem
In a competitive environment, the most skillful are valued. The less skillful just make defeat more probable and hereby become a burden on the team.
Cooperation enhances self-esteem.
Character building and ethics
When much is at stake and few can be winners, cheating, and dishonesty flourish in a hyper competitive climate.
Focus on Culture: Competition and Culture
Cooperation
|
Hyper competition
|
Improvement of achievement/ performance
|
Diminishment of achievement/ performance
|
Efficient utilization of resources
|
Hoarding of resources
|
Goal of achieving excellence
|
Goal of beating others
|
Promotion of harmonious relationships
|
Fostering of antagonism/ divisiveness
|
Increased cohesiveness
|
Diminished cohesiveness for "losers"
|
Enhancement of self-esteem
|
Creation of "failure factory"
|
Encouragement of openness;/ honesty
|
Encouragement of cheating/ dishonesty
|
Teamwork: Constructing Cooperation in Groups
In order for teamwork to work it must become systematic and that requires cooperation structured into the framework of the group for the benefit of all members.
There are six elements necessary to establish a cooperative team structure:
1. Interdependence--All must work together to achieve the desired goal. The goal should be attainable only with cooperation and success should be defined in terms of the group.
2. Equality - Equal distribution of rewards provides potential motivation for all team members and enhances mutual self-esteem, and respect, group loyalty, and congenial personal relationships within the group.
There are three ways rewards can be divided
Merit system-Winner takes it all -this sets up competition
While 80% surveyed showed they favored merit pay for teachers, a survey of 3,000 studies show that there is either no positive results of serious disadvantages, such as divisiveness and demoralization, from merit pay schemes.
Equitable distribution (proportional)
Equal distribution
3. Participation-Participative decisonmaking is essential to the institution of cooperation in groups.
 Group members must have a stake in the outcome for cooperation to occur.
 First, group members participation in decision making is valued, encouraged, and respects.
 Second, the decisions of the team (subsystem) are valued, encouraged, and respected by the system as a whole.
 A review of 47 studies revealed that meaningful participation in decisonmaking increased worker productivity and job satisfaction.
4. Individual Accountability- Individual accountability merely establishes a floor below which no one should drop, not a ceiling that a very few can reach.
5. Cooperative Communication Patterns-Learning cooperative communication patterns is vital if you hope to build teamwork
Jack Glibb (1961) in an eight year study of groups, identified specific communication patterns that both increase and lessen defensiveness.
Defensive
|
Supportive
|
Evaluation
Criticism, contempt, blame
Positive evaluation such as praise and recognition are O.K.
|
Description- Is a first person report of how an individual feels.
I feel...
Specific description...
Eliminate editorial comments...
"I feel awkward and embarrassed when you tell my boss jokes that ridicule gays and women."
|
Control
Psychological Reactants Theory says that the more that someone tries to control us by telling us what to do, the more we are inclined to resist such efforts, even do the opposite.
"There are three ways to get something done--do it yourself; hire someone to do it; forbid your kids to do it." Ann Landers
|
Problem Orientations
When executives asked fro problem solving ideas from colleagues, 96% of the plans were approved, When executives overseeing the plan attempted to impose their ideas on colleagues, they were rejected 58% of the time
(From a study of 356 US companies)
|
Strategy
Most people resist being manipulated.
|
Spontaneity
More specifically straightforwardness--directness and honesty. Don't play games with me, I don't like it.
|
Neutrality
Indifference to group members makes us defensive. When members make little of not effort to listen to what another has to say they are treating that communicator as a non person. Failure to acknowledge another person's communication effort is called an impervious response.
|
Empathy
You counter indifference with empathy. Empathy is built on sensitivity to others.
|
Superiority
A superior attitude is a turnoff for most people.
|
Equality
Equality in a group means that we give everyone an equal opportunity to success
|
Certainty
Dogmatism is the belief in the self-evident truth of one's opinion.. Closed minded and rigid thinking results in resentment, tension and deterioration of trust.
|
Provisionalism
Shuns absolutes and encourages openness to new possibilities and counters certainty
|
Closer Look: The Robbers Cave Experiment
When groups perceive advantages to cooperating, they will cooperate. . "In short, hostility gives way when groups pull together to achieve overriding, superordinate goals which are real and compelling to all concerned. "
6. Noncompetitive listening
 A report from the US Department of Labor reveals that the average worker spends about 55% of time on the job listening to others.
 College students devote more than half of their communicating time to listening.
 One study discovered that during a lecture
 12% were actively listening
 20% were mildly attentive
 20% were pursing mildly erotic thoughts
 20% reminiscing
 8% worrying, daydreaming, thinking about lunch or religion
Encouragement is Oxygen to the Soul- John Maxwell
Shift response versus Support response
Shift response --the listener attempts to shift the focus of attention from others to oneself by changing the topic of discussion
Support response--this is an attention giving, cooperative effort by the listener to focus attention on the other person, not on oneself.
Competitive interrupting
 Competitive interrupting is me- oriented, the focus is on individual needs not group needs
 Competitive interrupting creates antagonism, rivalry, hostility, and in some cases withdrawal from group discussion by frustrated members.
Ambushing
 Ambushers aim is to defeat the speaker in a verbal jousting match.
 Preparing a rebuttal while a speaker is still explaining shows little interest in comprehending a matter.
Two things that can shortcut ambushing are
Probing-
Clarifying questions: Can you give me an example of a foal for the group
Encouraging questions- Who can blame us for making a good effort to try a new approach?
Paraphrasing
A speaker restates the essence of the other's content in the listeners words
Gung Ho!
Turn on the People in Any Organization
by Ken Blanchard and Sheldon Bowles
Excerpts from the book beginning on page 170
Spirit of the Squirrel: Worthwhile Work
Knowing we make the world a better place.
 It's the understanding not the work
 It's how the work helps others, not units dealt with.
 Result: Self esteem--an emotion whose power ranks right up there with love and hate.
Everyone works toward a shared goal.
 Goal sharing means buy-in, not announcing. Trust and putting team members first lead to support for goals.
 The manager sets critical goals. The team can set the rest. (People support best that which they help to create.)
 Goals are marker posts you drive into the future landscape between where you are and where you want to be. They focus attention productively.
Values guide all plans, decisions, and actions.
 Goals are for the future. Values are now. Goals are set. Values are lived. Goals change. Values are rocks you can count on. Goals get people going. Values sustain the effort.
 Values become real only when you demonstrate them in the way you act and the way you insist others behave.
 In a Gun Ho organization, values are the real boss.
Way of the Beaver: In Control of Achieving the Goal
A Playing field with clearly marked territory.
 Goals and values define the playing field and rules of the game.
 Leaders decide what position team members play but then have to get off the field and let the players move the ball.
 Freedom to take charge comes from knowing exactly what territory is yours.
Thoughts, feelings, needs, and dreams are respected, listened to, and acted upon.
 You can't be in control unless the rest of the organization supports you and doesn't rip you, or your work, apart.
 Golden rule of Management: Value individuals as persons.
 Information is the gatekeeper to power. Everybody needs full open access to information. Managers must be willing to five up the levers of control they've worked a lifetime to get hold of. It's tough to be the boss without being bossy.
Able but challenged.
 Production expectations should be within capacity and skills, but if you undershoot you'll insult.
 Nothing drains self-esteem faster than knowing you're ripping off the system, not contributing. If people can't do a fair day's work for a fair day's pay, you demean them.
 Gung Ho requires a stretch: Work that demands people's best and allows them to learn and move into uncharted territory.
Gift of the Goose: Cheering Others On
Active or passive congratulations must be true
 Congratulations are affirmations that who people are and what they do matter, and that they are making a valuable contribution toward achieving the shared mission.
 Telling people what a great job they've done or presenting an award is an active congratulation. Passive congratulations are such things as stepping aside and letting a team member go forward with a tricky, complicated, important project, without exercising control or even offering advice.
 You can't overdo TRUE congratulations: Timely, Responsive, Unconditional, Enthusiastic.
No score, no game, and cheer the progress
 At football games fans don't sit mute as the ball is moved down the field, waiting for the touchdown before cheering. Cheer the progress, not just the results. Measurement (score) shared with everyone generates excitement.
 The farther congratulations are to the right of the scale below, the better (more effective) they are:
Programmed --Spontaneous
Blanket --Individual
General--Specific
Traditional --Unique
 Stop focusing on problems and the guilty party (police behavior) and start looking for those responsible for things gone right (coach behavior).
E=MC2-Enthusiams equals mission times cash and congratulations
 Worthwhile work and being in control of achieving the goal--that's a mission
 Cheering each other on brings enthusiasm to work
 Cash comes first--you need to feed material needs, (food clothing, etc.) before you can feed the spirit with congratulations.
Try this:
Make a list of positive affirmations you can make
That are individual specific and unique
Dealing with Difficult Group Members
 Make certain the group climate is cooperative
 Change your communication in relation to a difficult person's behavior
 Don't placate the troublemaker- don't tolerate bad behavior to uphold the illusion of harmony
 Refuse to be goaded into a reciprocal pattern-Don't counter abusive remarks with abusive remarks.
 Have an out of body experience- Remove yourself mentally from the conflict, listen as if you were an uninvolved third-party
 Don't provide a soapbox for the troublemaker.
 Attempt to convert disruption into a constructive contribution.
 Confront the person directly
 If all else fails separate yourself from the difficult group member.
Failure is only failure
If we do not learn from it.
John Maxwell
|